Common Mistakes in Hurstville Property Investing

Avoid the borrowing, structure and tax missteps that can quietly erode returns on an investment property in Hurstville and surrounds.

Hero Image for Common Mistakes in Hurstville Property Investing

Investment loan mistakes often come from choosing a structure first and checking the numbers second. If you are weighing up an investment property in Hurstville, this article covers common errors investors make and how to avoid them.

Why Does Borrowing Capacity Catch Investors Out?

Your borrowing capacity is the amount a lender is willing to lend after testing your income, debts and living costs at a higher rate than the loan's actual rate. Banks regulated by APRA must assess new borrowers at a rate at least 3.0 percentage points above the loan rate, as confirmed in APRA's May 2026 update.

That means a repayment you can comfortably afford today may still fail the bank's test. Existing debts count too, including credit card limits, which lenders can assess based on the limit rather than the balance. Before you start inspecting properties, get your borrowing capacity assessed so your search is built around a real number.

Rental income helps, but not in full. APRA's guidance says prudent lenders count no more than 80 per cent of expected rent, to allow for periods when the property is empty. Each lender sets its own policy on what rental evidence it accepts, so the same property can produce different results at different lenders.

Is Interest Only the Right Choice for an Investment Loan?

Interest only repayments lower your cash outflow during the interest-only period, but they do not increase how much you can borrow and they do not reduce the loan. Lenders assess an interest-only loan as if you will pay principal and interest over the shorter remaining term, which usually lowers your maximum loan size.

As an example, consider an investor with a $600,000 loan at an illustrative rate of 6.75% p.a. On interest only, the annual interest is $40,500, or about $3,375 a month. Over a 30-year principal and interest term at the same rate, the repayment is about $3,891 a month. Choose a 5-year interest-only period and the loan then switches to principal and interest over 25 years. At the same 6.75%, that repayment is about $4,145 a month.

The outcome: the investor saves roughly $516 a month during the interest-only period compared with a 30-year principal and interest loan. When the period ends, the repayment is about $254 a month higher than the 30-year figure and the full $600,000 is still owing. Interest-only suits investors who have a clear plan for the extra cash flow and can handle the step up. Use the mortgage repayment calculator to test your own numbers.

Only the interest portion of any repayment is tax deductible. The principal portion is not. Speak with your accountant about how this applies to you.

Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at Solara Financial today.

Does Negative Gearing Still Work for New Investors?

Negative gearing rules now depend on when you bought and what you bought. Losses on residential investment properties held at 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026, including those under contract at that time, can still be deducted against other income, such as salary, until the property is sold.

For established residential properties acquired after that time, net rental losses from the 2027-28 income year can only be deducted against other residential property income, including residential capital gains. Excess losses carry forward. Eligible new builds acquired after 12 May 2026 can still use losses against all income.

This changes the calculation for investors who rely on a tax refund to make the cash flow work. Interest remains deductible, but how you use a net loss is different. Rules around new builds are specific, so a knock-down rebuild that does not add dwellings is not eligible. Get advice from your accountant before you commit, as your outcome depends on your own circumstances.

How Do Capital Gains Tax Changes Affect Your Holding Period?

The 50 per cent CGT discount continues to apply to gains accruing before 1 July 2027 for individuals, trusts and partnerships holding an asset for more than 12 months. From 1 July 2027, it is replaced with CPI cost base indexation and a 30 per cent minimum tax rate on real gains accruing from that date.

For property you already own and sell later, the gain is split. The portion accruing before 1 July 2027 follows the current rules and the portion after follows the new rules. You can use a market valuation at 1 July 2027 or an ATO apportionment formula. Eligible new builds can elect either method. Your accountant can model which treatment suits your plan.

What Does Equity Release Do to Your Tax Position?

Using equity from an existing property to fund an investment purchase is common, but the tax treatment depends on how the borrowed money is used, not on which property secures the loan. Under ATO ruling TR 2000/2, each drawdown is treated as its own borrowing, and interest on funds used for private purposes is not deductible.

Consider an investor who draws $100,000 from their home equity. If they put $80,000 toward an investment deposit and spend $20,000 on a renovation of their own home, only the $80,000 portion is linked to an income-producing purpose. The cleanest approach is to keep investment and private borrowing in separate loan splits from the start. The outcome is a clear paper trail for your accountant at tax time.

The trade-off is more loan accounts to manage and potentially more lender fees, depending on the lender. Lenders also set their own limits on equity release, and borrowing above 80 per cent of the property value generally requires lenders mortgage insurance, which you pay as a premium. A mortgage broker can compare lenders across investment loans and show you the structure that fits.

Should You Refinance Your Existing Loans Before Buying?

Reviewing your current loans before you buy may help identify whether a different structure or lender suits you, but it is not always worth it. A loan health check shows whether your existing rate, features and structure still suit your investment plan.

If you do decide to switch, refinancing can bring a lower rate, depending on your lender and loan size. The trade-off is that refinancing may involve discharge, valuation and other fees, which vary by lender, so compare those costs against the savings before you proceed. Lenders may also revalue your property, which can affect how much equity you can use.

What Should You Check Before Buying in Hurstville?

Before buying in Hurstville, check the building's finances if it is a unit, confirm realistic rent from the evidence a lender will accept, and test your cash flow with a buffer for vacancies and higher rates. Hurstville is a well-known commercial and transport hub in Sydney's south.

For apartments, read the body corporate records. High levies reduce your net return and unexpected special levies can strain cash flow. Lenders also look at the property itself, so check how the lender views the building before you rely on a particular loan.

If you are comparing properties, work out the repayment at your illustrative rate, deduct realistic holding costs such as council rates, insurance, management fees and repairs, then see what the weekly shortfall or surplus looks like. If the property only works when everything goes right, it is the wrong property.

Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you. We will check your borrowing capacity, compare lenders and set up a structure that supports your investment plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does interest only increase how much I can borrow?

No. Lenders assess interest-only loans on principal and interest repayments over the shorter remaining term, which usually lowers the maximum loan size. Interest only reduces your repayments during the interest-only period but the loan balance stays the same.

Can I still negatively gear an investment property?

It depends on when you bought and what you bought. Properties held at 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 and eligible new builds keep current treatment, while later established purchases face restrictions from the 2027-28 income year. Ask your accountant how it applies to you.

Is interest on equity I release always tax deductible?

No. Deductibility depends on how the borrowed funds are used, not on the property securing the loan. Funds used for private purposes are not deductible, so keeping loan splits separate helps. Check with your accountant.

How much of my expected rent will a lender count?

APRA's guidance says prudent lenders count no more than 80 per cent of expected rent. Each lender sets its own policy on the rental evidence it accepts.


Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at Solara Financial today.