Renting vs buying: Is it worth it in Kogarah?

Buying a home in Kogarah means paying around $1.2 million for a unit or $1.8 million for a house, while renting a two-bedroom unit costs roughly $600 per week.

The question isn't which option costs less upfront. Renting always wins that comparison. What matters is whether the long-term cost of renting outweighs the immediate financial stretch of buying, and whether you can actually afford to buy without putting yourself under pressure that makes homeownership a burden rather than an asset.

What buying really costs in Kogarah right now

Buying a $1.2 million unit in Kogarah with a 10% deposit means borrowing $1.08 million, paying around $30,000 in stamp duty, and covering legal fees and inspection costs that add another $3,000 to $5,000. Your total upfront cost sits around $153,000 before you make your first mortgage repayment.

At current variable rates, a $1.08 million loan on a principal and interest basis runs close to $6,500 per month. Add strata fees of around $1,200 per quarter and council rates of roughly $1,400 per year, and your monthly outgoings land around $7,000. Compare that to paying $2,600 per month in rent for a similar property, and the gap is significant.

That gap narrows over time. Your mortgage repayments build equity with every payment, while rent delivers nothing back. After five years of repayments, you'll own around $150,000 of that property outright, assuming property values hold steady. Rent over the same period delivers zero ownership.

Renting keeps you mobile but costs you equity

Renting works when you value flexibility over ownership or when you're not financially ready to commit to a mortgage. If you're uncertain about staying in Kogarah long-term, or if your income fluctuates, renting removes the pressure of servicing a large loan amount.

But renting also means you're building equity for someone else. Over ten years, paying $600 per week in rent costs you $312,000 with nothing to show for it except occupancy. If rent increases by just 3% annually, that figure climbs to $354,000. Meanwhile, ten years of mortgage repayments on a $1.08 million loan leaves you owning around $350,000 of your property, even without factoring in capital growth.

Kogarah's proximity to the CBD, strong local schools, and established infrastructure mean property values tend to hold or appreciate over time. Renting might feel more affordable month to month, but it locks you out of any future gains in property value.

When buying makes sense despite the higher cost

Buying works when you can manage the repayments without stretching your income to breaking point, and when you plan to stay in the area long enough to recover your upfront costs.

Consider a buyer who earns $110,000 annually and has saved a $120,000 deposit. Their borrowing capacity supports a loan around $900,000, which opens up entry-level units in Kogarah. Using an offset account linked to their home loan, they can park their salary and any savings to reduce the interest charged on their loan. Over the life of the loan, this strategy can save tens of thousands in interest without changing their repayment amount.

If this buyer plans to stay in Kogarah for at least five years, buying delivers financial stability that renting cannot. Their monthly outgoings might be higher initially, but they're locking in a fixed cost base while building equity. Meanwhile, their rental counterpart faces rising rent every year with no end point.

How Lenders Mortgage Insurance affects the equation

If your deposit sits below 20% of the property price, you'll pay Lenders Mortgage Insurance. On a $1.2 million unit with a 10% deposit, LMI adds around $30,000 to your upfront costs. That's a substantial additional expense that delays the point at which buying becomes financially worthwhile compared to renting.

You can capitalise LMI into your loan rather than paying it upfront, but that increases your loan amount and your monthly repayments. For first home buyers in Kogarah, accessing government schemes that waive LMI on properties up to certain price caps can remove this cost entirely, but Kogarah median prices often sit above those thresholds.

If you're close to a 20% deposit, waiting a few more months to avoid LMI might make more financial sense than rushing into a purchase. Paying an extra six months of rent while you save could cost $15,600, but avoiding $30,000 in LMI means you're still ahead.

Fixed rate versus variable rate when buying in a rising market

Locking in a fixed interest rate protects you from rate rises but removes flexibility if rates fall. Right now, variable rates offer access to offset accounts and the ability to make extra repayments without penalty, which matters if you want to reduce your loan faster.

A split loan gives you both. You might fix 60% of your loan to protect against rate increases while keeping 40% on a variable rate with an offset account attached. This approach balances certainty with flexibility, and it suits buyers in Kogarah who want to protect their repayments while still benefiting from any rate cuts down the track.

If you're buying close to your maximum borrowing capacity, fixing at least part of your loan removes the risk that a rate rise pushes your repayments beyond what you can comfortably manage. That security matters more than chasing the lowest rate if it means you can hold onto the property long-term.

What the Kogarah rental market tells you about timing

Kogarah rental vacancy rates sit low, which means rents are under upward pressure. When rental supply tightens, landlords increase rents, and tenants have limited negotiating power. Over the past few years, weekly rent for a two-bedroom unit in Kogarah has climbed from around $500 to $600, a 20% increase that outpaces wage growth for most buyers.

If you're renting now and watching your rent climb every year, buying locks in your housing cost. Your mortgage repayment might be higher today, but it stays relatively stable while rent continues rising. Over a ten-year period, that stability becomes a significant financial advantage, particularly if you're on a fixed income or planning for retirement.

Buying also gives you control. You're not subject to lease renewals, landlord decisions to sell, or rent increases that force you to move. For families with children in local schools like Kogarah High School or St George Girls High School, that stability has value beyond the financial equation.

Calculating your own position

Your decision depends on your deposit size, your income stability, and how long you plan to stay. If you can cover a 20% deposit, manage repayments comfortably at current rates, and plan to stay in Kogarah for at least five years, buying delivers better long-term value than renting.

If your deposit sits below 20%, or if your income fluctuates, renting might make more sense until your financial position strengthens. Rushing into a purchase with a marginal deposit and maximum borrowing capacity leaves no buffer if rates rise or your circumstances change.

Running your specific numbers through a loan health check shows you exactly where you sit and whether buying now, waiting six months, or continuing to rent makes the most financial sense for your situation. The answer varies depending on your income, your savings, and your goals, and there's no single right answer that applies to everyone.

Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you to work through your numbers and see whether buying in Kogarah makes sense for you right now.

Frequently Asked Questions